ACROSS THE CHANNEL
The public record

Documents & Updates

Campaign developments and correspondence about the Opua–Ōkiato ferry, with responses available to read in full.

Your experience matters

How does the crossing affect your everyday life? Share your ferry experience privately to help explain the community’s transport needs. A few sentences are enough.

Campaign correspondence · Grant’s reply: · Our response:

Grant advises waiting for the Commission process; parallel transport assessment requested

Grant McCallum acknowledges that the community’s concerns extend beyond fares to affordability, reliability and the ferry’s role as an essential transport link. He advises that the matter has been raised with Minister Brewer and a response is pending regarding a possible Commerce Commission investigation.

Grant’s position is to await clarity on the Commission’s position and the outcome of any investigation before progressing discussions with NZTA and other agencies.

Our response asks why the wider transport assessment cannot progress in parallel. It reiterates that the case for recognising the crossing as an essential transport link does not depend on demonstrating excessive profits, and seeks support for assessment without a commitment to a subsidy or particular funding outcome.

We have also requested the expected timing of Minister Brewer’s response, the next step if the Commission declines to investigate, and copies of correspondence for the public record. We are seeking a deputation to FNDC’s Transport and Infrastructure Committee.

A Commerce Commission investigation and a wider transport assessment have not been confirmed.

Grant’s previously supplied letter to Minister Brewer, dated 5 October, remains available here (PDF).

Clarification sent, 22 October: We have acknowledged that Grant’s 5 October letter to Minister Brewer was already supplied. Our request for copies refers to any further correspondence or separate written approach to the Commerce Commission. The other questions in our response remain.

The correspondence below is reproduced from the emails supplied by Karin. Grant’s reply was sent at 7:49 pm on 21 October. Office contact details, signature graphics and the repeated earlier email chain are omitted. The preceding 19 October email is available below.

Grant McCallum’s reply — 21 October 2026

Good evening Karin,

Thank you for your email. I acknowledge that the community's concerns extend beyond ferry fares to the broader issues of affordability, reliability and the ferry's role as an essential transport link.

As discussed at our meeting, the first step is to establish whether an investigation by the Commerce Commission is warranted. We have raised the matter with Minister Brewer and are awaiting a response regarding the possibility of an investigation.

I believe it is important that we follow this process before progressing discussions with NZTA and other agencies. Any approach to these agencies is likely to raise questions about what has been considered by the Minister and the Commerce Commission, and what conclusions, if any, have been reached.

Once we have clarity on the Commerce Commission's position, and the outcome of any investigation should one proceed, we can review the findings and determine the appropriate next steps in addressing the wider transport issues you have raised.

I recognise the considerable time and effort that you and others in the community have put into gathering the background information and supporting evidence. This will remain valuable as we work through the process.

Regards
Grant

Our response to Grant McCallum — 22 October 2026

Hi Grant,

Thank you for your reply. Is there a specific reason the wider transport assessment needs to wait for the Commerce Commission’s findings, rather than progressing alongside them?

Our case for the ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network does not depend on showing that the operator is making excessive profits. The hardship accounts I’ve shared concern people who rely on this crossing for everyday life. Ferry costs also affect visiting family, tourists, tradespeople and the wider Russell economy.

I’m concerned these transport needs will remain on hold while the Commission process unfolds. I’m asking for support to have the question assessed, without seeking a commitment to a subsidy or any particular funding outcome.

Could you please confirm whether you would support progressing that assessment in parallel? I would also appreciate knowing when you expect a response from Minister Brewer and what the next step would be if the Commission declines to investigate.

Please also provide a copy of your correspondence with Minister Brewer and any written request to the Commerce Commission, including attachments, and confirm whether these may be published on the Across the Channel documents page. This will help us keep the community accurately informed.

If your support at this stage is limited to the Commerce Commission approach, I’d appreciate knowing that clearly so we can pursue the wider question through other channels. In the meantime, we are seeking a deputation to FNDC’s Transport and Infrastructure Committee.

Kind regards,
Karin

Our clarification to Grant McCallum — 22 October 2026

Hi Grant,

Apologies—I already have your 5 October letter to Minister Brewer. I overlooked that when asking for a copy. That request should have referred to any further correspondence or separate written approach to the Commerce Commission.

The other questions in my email remain, particularly why the wider transport assessment needs to wait and whether you would support progressing it in parallel.

Kind regards,
Karin

Campaign correspondence ·

Ann Court declines sponsorship at this stage; committee deputation advised

Councillor Ann Court has responded to our request for coordinated transport action. She reports meeting the ferry operator and identifies FNDC’s Transport and Infrastructure Committee as a pathway for formal consideration. Her response sets out questions about responsibilities, funding, costs and resident discounts, and explains that she cannot presently confirm an organiser or timetable for a joint agency meeting.

We have asked Ann to sponsor the next step through the committee: a request for initial advice towards an assessment of the crossing’s transport role, agency responsibilities and options for affordable, reliable access.

Our reply clarifies that we are not advocating government subsidies or prescribing a change of ownership. We are seeking recognition of the ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network, and scrutiny of whether the current arrangements deliver affordable, reliable access. This includes examining operating costs, efficiency, margins and access to ferry infrastructure before assuming additional public funding is needed.

Further response, 21 October: Ann has replied that she is not able to commit to sponsor the assessment or confirm a date for its consideration at this stage. She reiterates that the community should request a deputation to the Transport and Infrastructure Committee, which would decide whether and how to proceed. She highlights staff time, costs, scope and access to information as considerations.

Our follow-up sent, 21 October: We have expressed our disappointment that Ann is not prepared to sponsor the assessment at this stage. We will pursue the deputation pathway and have asked for practical help navigating the process: the appropriate meeting and booking deadline, requirements and timing for supporting material, speaking time, how to frame a request the committee can formally consider, and who can assist us.

No committee assessment or joint agency meeting has yet been confirmed. Ann’s position is not a decision by the committee.

The correspondence below is reproduced from the emails supplied by Karin. Signature graphics, direct contact details, email-system notices and the repeated earlier chain are omitted. The council’s public governance email is retained because it forms part of Ann’s procedural advice.

Ann Court’s response — 21 October 2026

Good Morning Karin

Thank you for your email and your continued advocacy. I understand that affordability remains central to your campaign, alongside reliable access, and that these questions are separate from the Commerce Commission process.

Since we last communicated, I have met with the ferry operator. I found them open, informative and community focused. They explained the existing resident discount arrangements, which they advised provides a 50% reduction for eligible local postcode areas. They also provided some context around the impact of recent fuel price increases that they are currently absorbing and the impact this is having on their current operating model. That does not remove the affordability concerns you have raised, but it is an important part of understanding their current position.

The crossing is privately owned and operated. As an individual councillor, I cannot direct its fares or operations, commit Council resources, or appoint FNDC, NRC or NZTA to lead an assessment. Any proposed change involving the existing service would also need meaningful engagement with the operator. I am not aware of an agreed proposal from them for a different ownership or funding arrangement.

There may be lessons from Hokianga, but its council ownership and contractual arrangements make it a different starting point. Recognising this crossing as an essential transport link would not, by itself, establish public responsibility for its costs or secure NZTA funding.

Before advocating a particular model, I think decision makers would want to understand whether it would actually improve affordability for residents. That includes what would happen to existing discounts, whether NZTA funding would be available, what local funding would be required, and who would carry the ongoing operating and asset costs. Those questions remain unanswered.

To bring your request before FNDC, you can contact Democracy Services at governance@fndc.govt.nz and ask to present to the Transport and Infrastructure Committee. They can advise whether a deputation or public forum is the appropriate route and confirm the process and timing. Your request could seek initial advice on agency responsibilities and possible funding pathways, giving elected members a basis for considering any further work.

From my position, I cannot presently confirm an organiser or timetable for the joint agency meeting you have requested. Bringing the proposal before the committee would allow it to be considered collectively, including whether further investigation should be commissioned.

I appreciate the work your community has put into this. I want to ensure that any next step is grounded in what can realistically be achieved and what benefit it would deliver to ferry users.

Kind regards
Ann

Copied in Ann’s response: Cr Felicity Foy, committee chair; Cr Rachel Baucke, deputy chair; Natasha Rmandic, democracy support officer.

Our reply to Ann Court — 21 October 2026

Hi Ann,

Thank you for your response and for identifying the Transport and Infrastructure Committee as the appropriate pathway.

I am asking you, as an elected representative, to help take this request through that process. The community has provided substantial evidence; we now need councillor support to bring it forward for formal consideration.

To be clear, we are not advocating government subsidies or prescribing a change of ownership. We are seeking recognition of the crossing as an essential transport link and extension of the road network, alongside scrutiny of whether its current commercial, infrastructure and oversight arrangements deliver affordable, reliable access.

That assessment should examine operating costs, efficiency, margins and the arrangements governing access to the ferry infrastructure. It should establish whether affordability could be improved through changes to those arrangements before assuming additional public funding is needed. Engagement with the operator could form part of that work.

The unanswered questions you identify—agency responsibilities, funding eligibility, local costs and protection of resident discounts—are precisely why we have requested an assessment. Establishing those answers is the next step, rather than something the community should be expected to resolve before Council considers investigating.

Will you work with the committee chair and relevant staff to bring forward a request for initial advice on the crossing’s transport role, agency responsibilities and pathways for assessing these options? Please confirm whether you will sponsor that step and when it could be considered.

I am happy to present the community’s evidence and attend a meeting. What we need from our representatives is active support to progress this through Council.

Kind regards,
Karin
Across the Channel

Ann Court’s further reply — 21 October 2026

Hi Karin

I appreciate that the community would like this matter progressed. As I have outlined, the appropriate pathway is through the Transport and Infrastructure Committee. It is for the committee to consider your request and determine whether and how to proceed, rather than for me to make that commitment individually.

As discussed the next step is for the community to request a deputation slot at the committee. This would provide an opportunity to present your case, explain the assessment you are seeking and specify what you are asking the committee to support.

A deputation provides a pathway for your request to be heard. It does not commit the committee to commissioning advice or an investigation, and identifying that pathway does not constitute an undertaking from me to sponsor the work.

The resource implications are important. Even “initial advice” requires staff to review material, establish responsibilities, consider existing arrangements and prepare a response.

That work costs money and draws on staff time already allocated to other Council priorities. Those costs arise whether or not the assessment ultimately recommends additional public funding.

The broader examination you describe—covering operating costs, efficiency, margins and infrastructure access—is a substantial undertaking.

Before commissioning it, the committee would need to consider Council’s role, the proposed scope, access to the necessary information, likely costs and where the work would sit alongside existing commitments.

I am not suggesting that the conversation is without merit or that the community must resolve every outstanding question. However, asking Council to investigate those questions is a request to commit public resources. The committee needs to weigh that request alongside its other responsibilities.

At this stage, I am not able to commit to sponsor the assessment or confirming a date for its consideration. Requesting a deputation is the appropriate next step to put the community’s case before the committee so it can consider how to proceed.

I hope this clarifies the steps required.

Kind regards

Our follow-up: help navigating the deputation process — 21 October 2026

Hi Ann,

Thank you for clarifying that you are not prepared to sponsor the assessment at this stage. That is disappointing, as we were seeking active councillor support to bring the matter forward for collective consideration.

We will pursue the deputation pathway you have identified.

I have not navigated this committee process before and need practical assistance to bring the community’s request forward.

Could Natasha or the appropriate Democracy Services staff member please help arrange a deputation and explain:

  • The next available meeting and the deadline for requesting a slot.
  • What supporting material I need to provide and when.
  • How long I would have to speak.
  • How to frame a request that the committee can formally consider and decide upon.

Please confirm who can assist me through this process. I am willing to present the community’s case, but need clear guidance from Council on how to do so effectively.

Kind regards,
Karin
Across the Channel

Campaign correspondence · · Response requested by 30 October 2026

Following the update from Grant McCallum’s office, we have written to Grant, Jane Hindle and Ann Court asking for the wider transport issue to progress alongside the Commerce Commission approach.

The request seeks a coordinated meeting involving FNDC, NRC and NZTA to identify a lead agency, assess planning and funding options, and establish clear next steps towards recognising the ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network.

We have requested a response by Friday, 30 October 2026, identifying who can organise the discussion and a proposed timeframe. This is a request for action; a meeting and agency commitments have not yet been confirmed.

Full email to Grant McCallum, Jane Hindle and Ann Court

Subject: Ōpua–Ōkiato ferry: progressing the wider transport issue

Hi Grant, Jane and Ann,

Thank you, Grant, for raising the ferry concerns with Minister Brewer. We appreciate that action and the update from your office.

However, I am concerned that the Commerce Commission approach is becoming the sole focus, while the central purpose of our campaign remains unresolved: recognition of the Ōpua–Ōkiato ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network, with clear public responsibility for affordable, reliable access.

Even if the Commission finds no grounds for an investigation, that transport-policy question will remain. Residents’ dependence on the crossing does not hinge on whether the operator has breached competition law.

At our September meeting, we discussed returning to this wider objective after the initial Commerce Commission approach. Now that the letter has been sent, I am asking that we progress the transport issue in parallel rather than wait indefinitely for that process.

Could you please help arrange a meeting involving FNDC, NRC and NZTA to establish:

  • Which agency will lead an assessment of the crossing’s role in the transport network.
  • What planning and funding pathways could support affordable, reliable access, including what can be learned from the Hokianga ferry arrangements.
  • What formal decisions are needed, who will take them forward, and on what timetable.

Grant, could you also raise this wider issue with the Minister of Transport? Jane and Ann, could you advise how to bring it formally before FNDC and the Regional Transport Committee?

The community has supplied substantial background and evidence. We now need a coordinated process with a named lead and clear next steps.

Could you please respond by Friday, 30 October, identifying who can take responsibility for organising this discussion and a proposed timeframe?

Kind regards,
Karin
Across the Channel
https://acrossthechannel.nz

Campaign update · · Letter dated 5 October 2026

Grant McCallum raises ferry concerns with Minister Brewer

Grant McCallum’s office has confirmed that he has written to and spoken with Minister Brewer about the Ōpua–Ōkiato vehicle ferry. His letter, dated 5 October 2026, asks whether the Commerce Commission can examine ferry charges and the competitive circumstances surrounding the service.

The letter raises the operator’s market power, the effect of limited competition on charges, and whether contractual, infrastructure or ferry-ramp arrangements create barriers to competition. It also asks whether any conduct or use of market power warrants investigation under the Commerce Act.

Grant describes the ferry as an essential service, recognising its role in access to employment, healthcare, education, shopping and other everyday needs. We welcome this action and the update from his office.

As of 19 October, Grant’s office advises that the letter has been acknowledged, but a substantive response is still pending. A Commerce Commission investigation has not been confirmed.

Read Grant’s letter to Minister Brewer (PDF)

The wider goal remains

Read our 19 October request for coordinated transport action above.

Alongside scrutiny of ferry fares and competition, Across the Channel continues to seek recognition of the crossing as an essential transport link and extension of the road network, with clear public responsibility for affordable, reliable access.

Campaign update ·

Seeking progress and a meeting

Subsequent update, 19 October: Grant’s office has now supplied his letter to Minister Brewer and confirmed that a substantive response is pending. Read the latest update above.

We have followed up with Grant McCallum for an update on his approach to the Commerce Commission regarding ferry fares and community concerns, and requested a response by 23 October.

We have also requested a meeting with Hūhana Lyndon to discuss support for recognising the Opua–Ōkiato ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network. Hūhana is open to a face-to-face hui or Zoom, subject to her schedule; a meeting has yet to be confirmed.

Our campaign remains focused on affordability, reliability and clear public responsibility for this essential connection.

Read the correspondence below: our follow-up to Grant and the exchange with Hūhana.

Published · Follow-up sent 18 October 2026

Grant McCallum: progress update requested

We have followed up on our email of 5 October, asking whether Grant has spoken with the Commerce Commission and sent his letter. We have requested an update, a copy of any correspondence sent, and a response by Friday, 23 October.

We have also asked when we can revisit the wider goal of recognising the ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network, with clear public responsibility for affordability and reliability.

Full follow-up email to Grant McCallum

Hi Grant,

I’m following up on my email (05/10/2026) accompanying the 2003 judgment and historical Commerce Commission material. We requested an initial progress update within two weeks, even if a response from the Commission was still pending, and haven’t yet heard back.

Have you now spoken with the Commission and sent your letter? We would appreciate an update and a copy of any correspondence sent. If those steps are still pending, please let us know when you expect to take them.

We understand the Commission’s consideration may take time. In the meantime, knowing what action has been taken will help us keep the community accurately informed.

Our wider objective remains recognition of the ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network, with clear public responsibility for affordability and reliability. Please also confirm when we can revisit the next steps towards that goal.

Could you please respond by Friday, 23 October?

Kind regards,
Karin
Across the Channel

Published · Hūhana’s reply received 11 October 2026

Meeting with Hūhana Lyndon: scheduling requested

Hūhana Lyndon has indicated she is open to a face-to-face hui or Zoom meeting about the Opua–Ōkiato ferry issue, subject to her schedule. We have followed up to request a confirmed time within the next couple of weeks. A meeting has yet to be confirmed.

Read the correspondence

Our follow-up to Hūhana Lyndon

Kia ora Hūhana,

Thank you for getting back to me. A face-to-face hui would be great, and Zoom would also work.

I haven’t heard from Cassie yet. Could we please confirm a time to meet in the next couple of weeks. We’re keen to keep momentum going on the Opua–Ōkiato ferry issue and discuss how you can help move this forward.

Ngā mihi,
Karin

Hūhana Lyndon’s reply — 11 October 2026

Kia ora

I will see how I am placed for a hui face to face or alternatively we can have a zoom? Cassie can look at my schedule.

Ngā manaakitanga, nā

Published

Our response: a timeline and the wider goal

Our follow-up asks Grant McCallum for a timetable for his approach to the Commerce Commission, a copy of his correspondence, and an initial progress update within two weeks.

It also asks how he will help secure recognition of the ferry as an essential transport link and an extension of the roadway, with clear public responsibility for affordability and reliability.

Read our follow-up in full

Download our response (PDF)
Full response to Grant McCallum

Hi Grant,

Thank you for your response and for taking the time to meet with Cath and me.

Attached are the original 2003 judgment and the Commerce Commission material we discussed. Thank you for taking the concerns about ferry fares forward with the Commission.

Could you please let us know when you expect to speak with the Commission and send your letter? We would appreciate a copy of that correspondence and an initial progress update within the next two weeks, even if a response is still pending.

We also want to reiterate that our wider goal extends beyond a Commerce Commission investigation. We are seeking recognition of the Opua–Ōkiato ferry as an essential transport link and an extension of the roadway, with clear public responsibility for its affordability and reliability.

The ferry supports everyday access to work, education and healthcare, as well as suppliers and emergency services. Its role includes being called out at night for urgent hospital transport. These needs remain regardless of what the Commission concludes about fares or competition.

Alongside your approach to the Commission, could you please outline how you will help progress this wider goal with the relevant agencies, including FNDC, Northland Regional Council and NZTA, and clarify who should take the lead?

We appreciate your assistance and look forward to a clear path forward.

Kind regards,
Karin
Across the Channel

Published · Response received 3 October 2026

Grant confirms his first step

Following our meeting on 28 September, Northland MP Grant McCallum has confirmed in writing that his first step will be to speak with the Commerce Commission and then write to it about ferry fares and the concerns raised by the community.

He has also requested the original 2003 court judgment and historical Commerce Commission material to support that approach.

This is a welcome first step. An investigation has not yet been confirmed, and no timetable has been provided.

Across the Channel’s position: the wider question remains

Alongside scrutiny of fares, we are asking the responsible government agencies to recognise the Opua–Ōkiato crossing as an essential transport service and an extension of the road network, and to accept responsibility for ensuring affordable, reliable access.

Grant’s response does not yet address that request. It remains a central goal of this campaign.

Read the response in his own words

Download the response transcript (PDF)
Full email response from Grant McCallum

Transcript of the email response supplied by Karin. The response text is reproduced in full; the signature image and earlier email chain are omitted.

Hi Karin,

Thank you to you and Cath for taking the time to meet with Deirdre and me on Monday to discuss the Opua–Ōkiato ferry.

The extensive background and supporting information you provided, together with the additional material from Jane Hindle, has been very helpful. I recognise the considerable time and effort that has gone into gathering this information and setting out the history of the issues surrounding the ferry. I would also be grateful if you could send me a copy of the original 2003 judgment and the Commerce Commission material you mentioned.

As discussed on Monday, my first step will be to speak with the Commerce Commission and then write to them regarding the ferry fares and the concerns that have been raised.

Regards
Grant